For frozen custard enthusiasts, few dessert matchups generate more debate than Freddy’s Frozen Custard & Steakburgers versus Andy’s Frozen Custard. Both chains have built loyal followings by serving premium frozen custard instead of traditional ice cream, but their approaches are surprisingly different.
While Freddy’s focuses on pairing frozen custard with its famous steakburgers and savory menu items, Andy’s is a dessert-first concept known for elaborate concretes, sundaes, and its signature Jackhammers. Both brands offer rich frozen custard experiences, but differences in pricing, richness, customizations, and portion sizes can influence which one delivers the best value. Freddy’s Frozen Custard & Steakburgers Online Food & Drinks Menu Full Menu – Andy’s Frozen Custard.
What Makes Frozen Custard Different From Ice Cream?
Before comparing the two chains, it’s important to understand why frozen custard stands apart from standard ice cream.
Frozen custard typically contains:
- Egg yolks
- Cream
- Milk
- Less air than traditional ice cream
The reduced air content creates:
- Greater density
- Richer texture
- Creamier mouthfeel
- More indulgent flavor
Both Freddy’s and Andy’s rely on this premium texture as the foundation of their dessert menus.
Freddy’s Frozen Custard Overview
Freddy’s serves frozen custard alongside a full fast-casual restaurant menu. Customers can order everything from steakburgers and fries to sundaes, shakes, concretes, and custard sandwiches. The menu includes signature desserts such as the OREO® Double Trouble, Signature Turtle, Reese’s® Royale, Strawberry Dreamcake, and Create Your Own Concrete options. Freddy’s Frozen Custard & Steakburgers Online Food & Drinks Menu.
One of Freddy’s biggest strengths is flexibility.
Customers can choose:
- Concretes
- Shakes
- Malts
- Sundaes
- Floats
- Frozen custard dishes
The result is a dessert menu that appeals to both casual customers and dedicated frozen-custard fans.
Andy’s Frozen Custard Overview
Andy’s takes a more dessert-centered approach.
Its menu revolves around frozen custard treats such as:
- Concretes
- Jackhammers
- Sundaes
- Splits
- Shakes
- Seasonal creations
Popular Andy’s concretes include the BootDaddy Concrete, Triple Chocolate Concrete, Ooey Gooey Concrete, Snowmonster Concrete, Butter Pecan Concrete, Mint Chip Concrete, and Strawberry & Oreo Concrete. Full Menu – Andy’s Frozen Custard
In addition, Andy’s famous Jackhammers feature a frozen custard treat filled down the center with a topping such as hot fudge, creating a dessert experience that differs from typical concrete mixers. Full Menu – Andy’s Frozen Custard
Richness Comparison
Freddy’s Richness
Freddy’s frozen custard has a smooth and creamy texture while remaining relatively light compared with some specialty dessert shops.
The custard blends well with:
- Candy mix-ins
- Cookie pieces
- Fruit toppings
- Cheesecake bites
Many Freddy’s desserts emphasize balance over intensity.
Because Freddy’s also serves burgers and fries, the frozen custard is designed to function as either a meal-ending dessert or a standalone treat.
Andy’s Richness
Andy’s is often regarded by custard enthusiasts as more dessert-focused.
Many of the chain’s signature treats feature:
- Hot fudge
- Cookie dough
- Caramel
- Brownies
- Pecans
- Oreo® pieces
The combination of dense custard and generous toppings creates an especially indulgent experience. Full Menu – Andy’s Frozen Custard
Richness Winner
Andy’s Frozen Custard
While Freddy’s is undeniably creamy, Andy’s tends to lean harder into rich, over-the-top dessert creations.
Portion Size Comparison
Portion size is one of the largest differences between the two brands.
Freddy’s Portions
Freddy’s typically offers:
- Mini
- Regular
- Large
This allows guests to scale their dessert according to appetite.
For someone grabbing dessert after a burger combo, Freddy’s sizing often feels appropriate and manageable.
Andy’s Portions
Andy’s has developed a reputation for generous servings.
Many customers consider Andy’s portions:
- Larger than expected
- Ideal for sharing
- Suitable as a meal replacement dessert
Numerous Andy’s creations are designed as substantial indulgences rather than quick add-ons to lunch or dinner.
Portion Winner
Andy’s Frozen Custard
For pure volume and dessert-focused servings, Andy’s generally provides larger-feeling portions.
Pricing Comparison
Pricing varies by location, but both brands compete in the premium frozen dessert category.
Freddy’s Pricing Philosophy
Freddy’s desserts often feel integrated into a broader restaurant experience.
Advantages include:
- Convenient combo visits
- Multiple size choices
- Wide price range
- Easy customization
The chain’s dessert lineup accommodates customers looking for either a small treat or a large indulgence. Freddy’s Frozen Custard & Steakburgers Online Food & Drinks Menu
Andy’s Pricing Philosophy
Andy’s positions itself almost entirely around frozen custard.
Publicly available menu examples show many signature concretes priced around the mid-single-digit range, although pricing varies by location. Andy’s Frozen Custard Menu & Prices
Because portions are often larger, some customers perceive Andy’s as offering strong dessert value.
Pricing Winner
Tie
- Freddy’s often feels more affordable for smaller desserts.
- Andy’s can offer excellent value through larger portions.
Customization Options
Freddy’s
Freddy’s Create Your Own Concrete system enables customers to personalize desserts with numerous toppings and mix-ins. The menu also includes specialty concretes and seasonal flavors. Freddy’s Frozen Custard & Steakburgers Online Food & Drinks Menu
Andy’s
Andy’s embraces customization as a key part of its brand, with a large selection of toppings and flavor combinations for both vanilla and chocolate custard. Full Menu – Andy’s Frozen Custard
Customization Winner
Andy’s
Its dessert-focused menu provides slightly more flexibility and creativity.
Best Choice for Different Customers
Choose Freddy’s If:
- You want a burger-and-dessert experience.
- You prefer smaller portion flexibility.
- You enjoy shakes, floats, and concretes.
- You value convenience.
Choose Andy’s If:
- Dessert is your primary destination.
- You love larger servings.
- You enjoy rich toppings and mix-ins.
- You want signature creations like Jackhammers.
Which Brand Offers Better Value?
Value depends on what you’re seeking.
If you want:
- A quick dessert after dinner
- Multiple size options
- Convenience
Freddy’s often delivers the better overall experience.
If you want:
- Maximum indulgence
- Large portions
- Dessert-focused innovation
Andy’s frequently comes out ahead.
Final Verdict
The battle between Freddy’s Frozen Custard and Andy’s Frozen Custard isn’t about which chain makes bad custard. Both are among the most popular frozen custard destinations in the United States.
For customers prioritizing richness and portion size, Andy’s has a slight edge thanks to its dessert-focused menu, generous servings, and creations like concretes and Jackhammers. Full Menu – Andy’s Frozen Custard.
For customers seeking variety, convenience, and flexible pricing, Freddy’s remains an outstanding choice with a menu that includes concretes, shakes, sundaes, floats, and customizable frozen custard treats. Freddy’s Frozen Custard & Steakburgers Online Food & Drinks Menu
Ultimately, dessert lovers may find the perfect solution is not choosing one over the other, but enjoying both whenever the craving for premium frozen custard strikes.
See More: Freddy’s Shoestring Fries vs. Culver’s Crinkle Cut Fries